Tuesday, 17 February 2015
Long Steady State Cardio or High Intensity Interval Training, Which Is The Best For Fat Burn?
I have been asked this question a couple of times this week, so I thought I would answer it to the best of my ability on here.
First lets look at the meanings and advantages of both.
Long steady state cardio first of all means to exercise for a long period of time while keeping the heart rate at a stable level. I would always advise clients who have very little exercise history to go start with LSS, it is less likely to lead to injury than intense interval training. Injury prevention is the priority for any good training programme, so for the unconditioned LSS is definitely the place to start. I would also say it's the better option for the calorie counters, some people just respond better to seeing the numbers in front of them. LSS burns more calories during the training session so for all those people out there counting their calories on my fitness pal, LSS might be for you.
A lot of body builders use this type of training due to the low intensity of it, it leaves them feeling fresh enough to weight train later on in the day. They are also able to work in the "fat burn zone" working at about 60-65% of your max HR.
Some people claim LSS can put you in a catabolic state, meaning that your body starts to break down muscle and convert it to glycogen to be used as energy. Now this maybe true in a sense but firstly it isn't going to effect the average gym goer who has only their lunch break to train in. Anything under 60 mins isn't going to have much of a catabolic effect. Secondly if you are working long enough that you reach the point where catabolism occurs, it is easily countered with an increase in protein intake throughout training days.
LSS can also be used on days where the more experienced trainers or athletes are feeling delicate. It can be really low impact and can even be helpful for recovery as it will help oxygenise tired muscles and can be helpful mobility when feeling stiff.
High Intensity Interval Training or HIIT means short sprint intervals couple with active recovery. I tend to enjoy this type of training more personally. I like lot of people tend to find LSS monotonous, so for me being able to work extremely hard for 4-10 minutes and still getting a fat burn and lung capacity benefit, appeals much more to me. Another benefit to HIIT is that it allows you time to do get more done during the same session. I will often start a session with some olympic lifting or other strength training disciplines and then finish with some HIIT.
Have you ever seen a fat sprinter? no, neither have I. Due to the fact HIIT challenges your lactic threshold and your anabolic threshold, your body will go through metabolic changes when training this way. This means that you'll continue to burn energy for a longer period of time in comparison with LSS.
HIIT is a more versatile type of cardio training. You can incorporate many different movements into your session. Things like burpies, squats, press ups, even sports specific movements such as agility and ball skills. These are things that you wouldn't be able to include in a long steady state programme.
You can do a HIIT session in just 4 mins! Tabata is a form of interval training and consists of 8 x 20s high intensity intervals separated by 10s of recovery. An effective cardio workout in just 4 mins, leaving you with the whole day ahead of you. This is one of the main reasons i recommend this to my more experienced clients.
At the end of the day, you will be able to find various research articles to fight the case for both of these methods of training. So i honestly believe that the most suitable method of cardio for burning fat is the one that you most enjoy doing, This is due to the fact that enjoying your training means you are more likely to do it. Like any training, make sure your programme is progressive. Whether you are doing HIIT or LSS alway look to take it to the next level.
If you want any more advice or would like to book in for a consultation, give me a call.
Tel - 07887497658
Email - chris.rowlatt@yahoo.com
Twitter - @chrisrowlatt
Facebook -https://www.facebook.com/pages/Chris-Rowlatt-Personal-Training/234081446787193
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment